Fitch revises Alliance Bank (Kazakhstan) ratings
27.12.13 11:17
/Fitch Ratings, London/Moscow, December 23, 13, heading by KASE/ – Fitch Ratings
has downgraded Kazakhstan's Alliance Bank JSC's Long-term Issuer Default Ratings
(IDRs) and senior unsecured bond rating to 'C' from 'CCC'. A full list of rating
actions is at the end of this rating action commentary.
KEY RATING DRIVERS
The downgrade of Alliance's IDRs to 'C' from 'CCC' and Viability Rating (VR) to
'c' from 'cc' reflects Fitch's view that the default is now probably imminent
in light of (i) recent statements by Alliance's new management that it plans to
initiate discussions with stakeholders, including the bank's creditors, to
recapitalize the bank; (ii) the bank's weak stand-alone financial position,
which may be worse than previously disclosed in light of additional
provisioning requirements identified by management; and (iii) the absence of
any plans of either the Kazakh authorities or the bank's new private
shareholder to recapitalize the bank without creditor participation.
In a recent presentation to creditors (subsequently published), management
highlighted the bank's weak capitalization, additional provisional requirements,
structurally weak profitability and tight liquidity. Specifically, management
estimated that the bank needs to create further KZT75bn-KZT95bn of loan
impairment reserves (equal to 11%-14% of gross loans, or 13%-16% of Basel I
risk-weighted assets at end-9M13).
At end-9M13, Alliance reported a low Basel II Tier I capital ratio of 2.4%; the
regulatory capital ratios were a higher 9.1% (Tier I) and 13.4% (total),
respectively, mainly due to lower impairment reserves in statutory accounts.
Fitch Core Capital was negative, mainly due to the deduction of deferred tax
assets (which are included in Basel capital).
Creation of the additional impairment reserves identified by management, coupled
with smaller announced write-downs of other assets, would result in the bank
reporting deeply negative equity in both regulatory and IFRS accounts. A full
write- down of the bank's subordinated obligations and recovery notes (in the
IFRS accounts) would, therefore, be insufficient to restore the bank's capital
position, meaning that some further recapitalisation measures will also be
required.
Fitch does not exclude the possibility that the bank's majority shareholder (67%
stake) National Welfare Fund Samruk Kazyna's (SK) or the expected new private
shareholder Bulat Utemuatov (acquiring a 16% stake from SK; has also purchased
an 80% stake in another failed bank, Temirbank, from SK) will make some
contribution to Alliance's recapitalization. However, the tone of the recent
statements in Fitch's view clearly indicated that the bank's senior creditors
will also be expected to participate in the recapitalisation.
The downwards revision of Alliance's Support Rating Floor to 'No Floor' from
'CCC' reflects Fitch's view that regulatory forbearance for the bank is
unlikely to be extended beyond the near term, and that any support from the
Kazakh authorities is unlikely to be sufficient to prevent default.
Management expect to present a more comprehensive assessment of capital
requirements in mid-January 2014 when, Fitch believes, forms of debt
restructuring affecting senior creditors (excluding depositors) are likely to
be proposed.
RATING SENSITIVITIES
Implementation of a restructuring of the bank's senior obligations, which, in
Fitch's view, involves a material reduction of terms relative to the original
contractual terms, would, in accordance with the agency's 'Distressed Debt
Exchange' criteria, result in the IDRs being downgraded to 'RD' (Restricted
Default).
Fitch does not expect to take any further rating action as a result of the
bank's announced intention, as part of its liquidity preservation measures, not
to make payments to holders of recovery notes, which are due this week. In
Fitch's view, the recovery notes do not represent obligations, default on which
would "best reflect the uncured failure of the entity", (as provided for in the
agency's rating definitions), and so would not trigger a downgrade of the
bank's IDRs to default level.
The rating actions are as follows:
Long-Term foreign currency IDR: downgraded to 'C' from 'CCC'
Short-Term foreign currency IDR: affirmed at 'C'
Long-Term local currency IDR: downgraded to 'C' from 'CCC'
Viability Rating: downgraded to 'c' from 'cc'
Support Rating: affirmed at 5
Support Rating Floor: revised to 'No Floor' from 'CCC'
Senior debt rating: downgraded to 'C' to 'CCC'; Recovery Rating 'RR4'
Subordinated debt rating: affirmed at 'C'; Recovery Rating 'RR5'.
Contacts:
Primary Analyst
Roman Kornev
Associate Director
+7 495 956 7016
Fitch Ratings CIS Ltd
26 Valovaya Street
Moscow 115054
Secondary Analyst
Aslan Tavitov
Associate Director
+7 495 956 7065
Committee Chairperson
Alexander Danilov
Senior Director
+7 495 956 2408
Media contacts:
Juliya Belskaya von Tell, Moscow,
tel. + 7 495 956 9908/9901,
julia.belskayavontell@fitchratings.com
[2013-12-27]